25+ Housemade Flavors
(flavors listed on the homepage)
Single Scoop :: Big Scoop :: Two Scoops
$3.25 :: $4.25 :: $5.25
In a sugar cone (v), cake cone or cup
Extras
Whipped Cream .75
Gluten Free Cone (v) $1
Waffle cone
Made from scratch $1
Sauces
Made in-house
Hot Fudge / Caramel / Peanut Butter / Strawberry (v) / Marshmallow
Toppings
Chocolate Chips / Rainbow Sprinkles / Chocolate Sprinkles / Rice Krispies, Cocoa Puffs, Lucky Charms, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Fruity Pebbles or Granola / Pretzel Bits / M&Ms / Roasted Nuts / Peanuts / Heath /Toasted Pecans / Gummy Bears / Pop Rocks
..................
Shakes & MALTS
Any Flavor or Combo
12 oz / 16 oz / 20 oz
$5 / $6 / $7
..................
Floats
Any Flavor + Any Soda
Affogato
Any flavor + Shot of espresso
Cold Fusion
Any flavor + Coca-cola + shot of espresso
Cold Brew Float
Any flavor + Thou Mayest Cold Brew
..................
Sundaes
Build Your Own
Any flavor + sauce + two toppings + whipped cream
Brownie Sundae
Housemade brownie + any flavor + sauce + topping + whipped cream
S'mores Sundae
Any flavor + graham crumbles + hot fudge + torched marshmallow
Build-a-Sandwich
Any flavor + two fresh chocolate chip cookies + any sauce + any toppings
(Plus rotating sundaes, announced in shop)
..................
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Classic
Chocolate chip cookie + Vanilla ice cream
Notorious PBC
Double chocolate cookie + Peanut Butter ice cream
Chocolate vs. Chocolate
Double chocolate cookie + Chocolate ice cream
The “Oraeo”
Double chocolate cookie + Vanilla Bean ice cream
Strawberry Matcha
Matcha green tea cookie + Strawberry ice cream
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie + Vanilla ice cream
Berry Pie
Pie Crust Rounds + Raspberry & Blueberry ice creams
PB&J
Peanut Butter Cookies + Fresh Strawberry Jam + Strawberry Ice Cream
Peanut Butter & S'Mores
Peanut Butter Cookies + S'mores Ice Cream
Breakfast Sandwich
Oat Cookies + Coffee Ice Cream
Cereal Chiller
Cereal Mallow Treat Cookies + Cereal Milk Ice Cream
..................
Boozey shakes $9.50*
Two Shots, blended with ice cream and served in a chilled glass
Coffee + Bailey's
Bailey's Liqueur & Thou Mayest Coffee ice cream
White Russian
Vodka with Vanilla Bean and Coffee ice creams
Orange Creamsicle
Vodka, Triple Sec and Vanilla Bean ice cream
Mint Chocolate Julep
Bourbon, Creme de Cacao with Mint and Chocolate Cookies ice cream
Cinnamon 'Toast'
Rumchata, Fireball Whiskey with Vanilla Bean and Cinnamon ice creams
Not-So-Dark & Stormy
Ginger Beer and Rum, blended with our current Fruit Sorbet or Vanilla Bean ice cream
boozey floats $9.50*
Buffalo Sweat Float
Tallgrass Brewery's Oatmeal Cream Stout, with Vanilla Bean or any flavor ice cream
KC Bier CO Dunkel
The great local Dunkel (medium-bodied beer) with Vanilla Bean or any flavor ice cream
Rum & Coke Float
Rum, Coca Cola and any flavor ice cream
Spiked Root Beer Float
Vodka, Root Beer and any flavor ice cream
Vodka Red Bull Float
Vodka, Red Bull and any flavor ice cream
Special: Vanilla & Bourbon $8
A tall shot of Tom's Town Bourbon, poured over a scoop of Vanilla Bean ice cream
Special: Caffe Amaro & Coffee $8
A tall shot of Thou Mayest & J. Rieger's Caffe Amaro, poured over a scoop of Coffee ice cream
*Alcoholic beverages must be consumed inside the premises by adults with ID, and cannot be offered in to-go containers. Served after 5pm Mon-Fri, and all weekend.
Beverages
FROM THE COOLER
Soda
Water
Juice
Thou Mayest Cold Brew Coffee (over ice or as a float!)
..................
FROM THE HOUSE
Chocolate Milk
Hot Chocolate
..................
COFFEE
Beans provided by Thou Mayest
Espresso
Latte
Cappucino
Mocha
Americano
Macchiato
Iced Latte
Add a shot
Add vanilla, fudge or caramel